Compare Replicator Plus vs S5
Comparison between the best 3D printers
Choose the best 3D printer at the best price. The cheapest 3D printers are here.
Buy a 3D printer here with 3D Fila.
 |
 |
|
| Modelo | Replicator Plus |
S5 |
| Buy Filament forMakerbot Replicator Plus | Buy Filament forUltimaker S5 | |
| Estimated price | $2099,00 | $6950,00 |
| Manufacturer | Makerbot | Ultimaker |
| Release Year | 2016 | 2021 |
| Print Volume [mm] | 165x295x195 | 330x340x300 |
| Printer Size [mm] | 410x528x441 | 495x585x780 |
| Weight [kg] | 18,3 | 20,6 |
| Power Loss Recovery | YES | YES |
| Enclosed printer | NO | YES |
| Bed Leveling | Automatic | Automatic |
| Filament End Sensor | YES | YES |
| Bed type | Heated | |
| Power supply system | Bowden | Bowden |
| Standard nozzle | 0,4 | 0,4 |
| Maximum Nozzle Temperature [°C] | 230 | 280 |
| Maximum Bed Temperature [°C] | 140 | |
| Maximum printing speed [mm/s] | 150 | 80 |
| Filament holder | YES | YES |
| Camera for supervision | YES | YES |
| Recommended filaments | PLA | PLA, ABS, PETG, PC, Nylon, Tritan |
| Recommended slicers | MakerBot Print Software | Cura |
| Maximum Resolution [mm] | 0,1 | 0,1 |
| Processor | ||
| Display | Display touchscreen 4,7'' | |
| Power Supply | 110/220V / 240W | 110/220V / 500W |
| Connectivity | USB / Wi-Fi | USB / Wi-Fi |
| Operating systems | Windows, Mac, Linux | Windows, Mac, Linux |
| Date of registration in the system | 2022-11-15 | 2022-11-08 |
| Release date | 2016 | 2021 |
| Extra features | The Replicator Plus printer is easy to use and has very good print quality. Its software is user-friendly and powerful, with USB, Ethernet, Wi-Fi and support for printing via pen drive. With a safe design for an open frame printer, it is relatively quiet. The Smart Extruder+ detects filament end and pauses printing automatically, in addition to notifying via apps. It has a large print volume, with a non-heated and coated print bed for easy removal of parts. It also has a webcam for remote monitoring of prints. | The Ultimaker S5 stands out for its easy loading and unloading of materials, automatic bed leveling and excellent print quality with resolutions from 60 to 400 microns. It has dual extruders, interchangeable print cores, advanced connectivity with Wi-Fi and LAN, and intuitive software. It includes a Wi-Fi camera for monitoring, a removable glass bed, and a large build volume, making it ideal for professional and creative environments. |
| Support for multiple colors and materials (AMS and CFS) | NO | NO |
Notes * |
||
| Cost-benefit | 6 / 10 | 2 / 10 |
| Hardware | 2.5 / 10 | 4.2 / 10 |
| Tela | . | . |
| Print volume | 3 / 10 | 4 / 10 |
| Performance | 1 / 10 | 1 / 10 |
Conclusion |
| In comparing the MakerBot Replicator Plus and the Ultimaker S5, several key factors come into play, particularly in relation to their capabilities, pricing, and overall value. The MakerBot Replicator Plus, released in 2016, offers a more affordable price point and is designed for users who seek a straightforward, user-friendly 3D printing experience. It provides a good range of features, including automatic bed leveling, a heated print bed, and a robust software ecosystem that facilitates easy operation. However, its limited print volume and less advanced material compatibility may restrict its use for more complex or professional applications. On the other hand, the Ultimaker S5, launched in 2021, is positioned at a significantly higher price point but justifies this with enhanced capabilities. It boasts a much larger print volume, higher maximum nozzle and bed temperatures, and the flexibility to work with a wider array of materials. Its features, such as dual extruders and advanced connectivity, cater to professional users or environments where quality and versatility are paramount. Despite its higher cost, its rating in cost-benefit analysis reflects a lower value, suggesting that users may be paying a premium for advanced features they may not necessarily require. Ultimately, the choice between the two models falls to the intended usage. For hobbyists or casual users, the MakerBot Replicator Plus presents a compelling option due to its ease of use and value. Conversely, for professionals or those involved in more demanding projects, the Ultimaker S5, despite its higher cost, may provide the necessary features and print quality suitable for serious applications. In conclusion, your decision should hinge on budget considerations and the specific demands of your 3D printing tasks. If you seek functionality without breaking the bank, the Replicator Plus makes a strong case. But for those needing advanced features and greater material versatility, investing in the S5 may yield better long-term results. |